Friday, February 2, 2007

Secret Postcards

I chose the postcard that is a picture of a classroom and says “Everyday I am asked to be a magician in a world where magic doesn’t exist”. I think this is suppose to be a teenager talking and the purpose of it is to show how tough it can be for a teenager in school. He/she could be having trouble in school and at the same time feel a lot of pressure from their parents to do very well in school. It could also be pressure from their peers to do things he/she knows is wrong. Having to deal with that could make them feel like they have to be a magician to do it right. He/she feels like they have to do amazing things in a world where it is impossible. It is completely over their head and they feel like they can not deal with it anymore.

I also chose the postcard with a picture of a fraternity party that says “I go to fraternity parties, wait for everyone to get drunk, and steal all their stuff”. I think this person made this postcard because they know stealing is wrong and they just wanted to get it out and tell someone but without getting in trouble for it. I think it is a male writing this postcard and he secretly does not like fraternity parties. Maybe he doesn’t get a lot of attention from girls and the guys aren’t very nice to him and this is his way of getting back at them. I also think he has low self-esteem and by making these people feel stupid that they got their things stolen he feels more powerful and smarter.

Another postcard I chose was the postcard with a diagram of a car accident and it says “I wonder what I’d say… to the person who almost KILLED me”. It seems to me that it was a hit-and-run accident and the person who got hit is very bitter about it. It looks like it was a bad accident and it probably totaled his/her car. Because it was a hit-and-run they the person who hit them did not have to pay the price for their actions and will not have to pay for the car that they hit. The person who got hit probably had major injuries and to add to that they knew that the person who caused their injuries was getting off the hook for it. They have so much anger towards this person that they would not even know what they would say if they met the person who caused them so much pain and frustration.

The last postcard I chose was the postcard with the picture of the mother and daughter that says “Mom, it KILLS ME when you call him Dad”. It seems to me like her father is no longer in her life and her mom has a new husband. It is really hard on kids when they lose a parent and for her mom to go replace the parent can be even more painful. In the picture it shows the mother and daughter having a good time together so it appears that they have a good relationship so you would think that the daughter could communicate to her mom how she feels about “the new dad”. But that is not the case since she had to do it in a postcard. It was that hurtful to her that she could not even share her feelings in person. The daughter probably also wanted to write it in a postcard so that everyone else could see it and other mothers or fathers could know how badly it can hurt a child to replace their father or mother.

1 comment:

Geeta Sadashivan said...

Brooke,

You do a good job of analyzing the emotional tone of the postcard and the ethos of its composer. But you should add to it by discussing how the details contribute to that effect.

For instance, in the "magician" postcard how do the geometric shapes and lines contribute to the feeling of pressure? Why do you think the postcard is in black and white?

In the fraternity party, why are the letters of the message written in a mix of colors? What effect is produced by the fact that none of the subjects in the postcard are making eyecontact with the viewer?
Isn't it significant for your argument that the postcard shows a couple of guys surrounded by a whole lot of girls?